Chocolate Chip Cookie Recipe

The Shameful Narcissist cooks??  Sometimes…when I want to eat, don’t want to (can’t afford to) order, and the husband isn’t around :p  This isn’t to say I don’t know how to cook, nor do I dislike doing so, but I’m more interested in the fruits of the labor rather than the labor itself, whereas he’s admitted to enjoying the process.  Also, standing for too long makes me dizzy, which is an irritating reason I don’t normally putter about the kitchen, but I will forgo and endure all of these things around this time of the year to make…

Chocolate Chip Cookies

Damn…looking at this is making me want to make some right now…at midnight…when I have to work in the morning.

You can thank Cupcakes and Machetes for inspiring and reminding me about this, and you should check out her Cookie Day post.  I want those peppermint sugar cookies in my mouth hole.

For my recipe, it’s from my (former though he still works in the same building for the same company just a different department) coworker’s (now) ex-wife who’d make him batches of these and pumpkin chocolate chip cookies to bring in every year around the holidays.  Alas, I don’t know where that pumpkin chocolate chip recipe is, because they were good, too, but this one has become a favorite among my family and IRL friends, and I want to share it with my blogger buddies!

  • 3/4 stick Butter Flavored Crisco
  • 3/4 cups brown sugar (light or dark, doesn’t matter)
  • 2 T milk
  • 1 T vanilla extract (if you can, splurge on the real stuff)
  • 1 tsp salt
  • 1 large egg
  • 3/4 tsp baking soda
  • 2 c flour
  • 1 c chocolate chips (I do half milk half white)

Pre-heat the oven to 350 (…maybe 375?  Nah, I’m pretty sure it’s 350, but it might vary depending on your oven.  Oh, you thought this was going to be a precise/I know exactly what the hell I’m talking about recipe?  No…no :D).  While the kitchen is getting toasty warm, you can either set out some cooling racks or brown paper bags if you don’t have the former.  The bags are fantastic for cooling cookies and absorbing some of the excess grease.

Mix the Butter Flavored Crisco (that’s the soft chewy secret.  Also, you cannot save any Crisco until next year.  You have to use it or else it loses its flavor.  Learned that the hard way when I made cookies one year with Crisco I’d kept in the sealed container it comes in.  When I tasted the cookie dough, it was damn near flavorless, and I’d wasted all of those ingredients.  Oops, back to the recipe…) with the brown sugar.  You can use a hand mixer or one of those fancy Kitchen Aids if you have one (my MIL bought me one a few years ago, and I never use it for some reason.  I think because it doesn’t fit on the counter so I’d have to move it, and in my ridiculous brain it just seems easier to pull out the hand mixer.  Wtf is with all the tangents…).  Mix in the milk then the vanilla.  Once all that is mixed, crack open the egg and add that in there, as well.

Now, the recipe I was given would have you separate all of the dry ingredients into another bowl.  You can do that if you want.  I just throw everything together into the one I’m already using, because as much as I’m sort of ambivalent on cooking, I abhor cleaning.  You can of course mix the dry ingredients (salt, baking powder, and flour) together in a separate bowl, slowly adding them into the wet ingredients, or you can do it TSN’s way.

Add the salt and the baking powder.  Mix it up.  Then add the flour about one cup at a time.  You may have to speed up your mixer when the dough becomes thicker.  If you’re feeling really feisty, you could mix all this manually with a spoon.  It’s quite a work out!

Once the dough is mixed, add in the chips (I usually use Ghirardelli, because fuck Nestle.  #sorrynotsorry They were bottling and selling water collected in California during a drought a few years ago.  They also use child slave labor.  Chocolate is a pretty big ethical topic, and I have no idea if Ghirardelli is even ethical…now I’m afraid to google it *groan*).  Like I said above I do half a cup milk chocolate and half a cup white chocolate, but you’re more than welcome to do a full cup of milk chocolate chips (or semi-sweet if milk is too much for you.  Your kitchen, your rules).  I’d advise against doing all white chocolate, as it’s a bit too sweet/candy like.  You can also forgo the chips entirely, and you’ll have a sort of dark sugar cookie.

Exhibit A

After you’ve finished tasting the dough (look I’m aware there’s raw egg in it, but it’s a risk I’m willing to take),

grab a decent sized spoon (or melon-baller is you have one of those), using said utensil to drop the cookie dough onto an ungreased cookie sheet.  I usually get about a dozen  or so on it.  (Oh!  Shit, almost forgot.  You can refrigerate the dough if you want, too.  Actually, if you throw it in the fridge for two hours or so, it’ll be easier to scoop and shape.  Plus I think the cookies will be sturdier.  It’s been a year,  peeps, I really don’t remember.)

Bake for seven minutes.  The recipe said ten, but the bottoms were too brown for my liking.  Seven minutes then pull the cookies out out, but leave them on the sheet.  They’ll actually continue cooking a bit more out of the oven on the warm pan.  They’ll be quite gushy, so attempting to remove them will just smoosh them.  Now if you like less chewy cookies, by all means keep them in the oven longer!  I’d cap the time limit at ten minutes, and for goodness’ sake, make sure you set a timer!  I’ve fallen into THAT trap quite often.  You can mess around with time between 7-10 minutes to see what suits you best.

While the one batch of cookies is warming/cooling on the sheet, load up another and pop it in the oven.  When they come out, you should be able to remove the cookies from the first sheet either with a spatula or a little twist of your fingers.  Put them on the cooling rack or paper bags.  They should be solid enough to move (or eat), and once you’re finished baking, you can transfer them to the container of your choice!

So that’s my chocolate chip cookie recipe.  I hope you weren’t too annoyed by my tangents and randomness.  Let me know if you use this recipe and how it turns out, and of course I’d be more than happy to answer any questions you might have.

Happy Baking and Happy Holidays!

15 thoughts on “Chocolate Chip Cookie Recipe

    • They really are a classic! So, I ALMOST recounted the erroneous story about the origin of them, but I figured I’d google it to make sure I wasn’t wrong, and it turns out I was haha. They were deliberately made in that way by the woman who owned Toll House :O

      I thought all chocolate chip cookies were brown sugar! I think that’s what gives them that darker coloring, but you could use dark brown OR light brown sugar with this recipe and I haven’t really noticed a difference 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  1. Not gonna lie, that was the most entertaining recipe I ever read 😀 These look so good but I can’t cook/bake to save my life. Do let me know if you find that pumpkin chocolate cookie recipe though! That sounds so divine I’d risk attempting to make it, haha.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Pingback: The Christmas Tag | The Shameful Narcissist Speaks

  3. I like your baking directions. Way more entertaining than the ones most cook books provide. 😛
    I’m so glad you mentioned the option of not adding the chips in, because that has always been my favorite way to enjoy chocolate “chip” cookies. lol People look at me like I’m nuts when I tell them that, but they’re soooo good that way! I do like the idea of trying them with milk AND white chocolate chips next time I make them for someone else, though. Thanks for sharing this recipe, they look and sound amazing. 🙂
    And I’m so with you on the 7 minutes baking time for cookies. I hate a hard, crunchy cookie, and they’re always so soft and delicious when you pull them while they’re still squishy and just let the residual heat finish cooking them.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Yaasss we can be cookie buddies lol. That came about when I needed to make them without chocolate because a coworker was allergic. They’re almost like a snickerdoodle just without the cinnamon! I actually just made some tonight since I give them out as presents and my brother has been asking about them lol.

      Right?? I like some cookies cruncy, but NOT chocolate chip. The gooeyer the better.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Pingback: The State of the Writer: 12/31/17 | The Shameful Narcissist Speaks

  5. Pingback: Amish Cinnamon Bread | The Shameful Narcissist Speaks

Leave a Reply to The Shameful Narcissist Cancel reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.