TSN’s 2017 Top Games List

Hello Dear Friends!  I hope you all had Happy Holidays and a Happy New Year.  This is (was) my favorite time: Christmas Night.  It’s the long exhale after the climax where everyone can relax and play with their presents, while basking in the relief that it’s over.  I saw some awesome videos of kids opening up presents on Christmas Morning (the Nintendo Switch unwrapping was amazing), and I, myself, received Final Fantasy XII: The Zodiac Age, Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild , my very own PS4, tons of git cards, a special vase, and a bunch of other awesome gifts!I’m (was) also off Tuesday and Wednesday and figured now is as good of time as any to (start working on)  post my 2017 Best of List for gaming before the elderly year grows older (sadly it died before I could finish.  Alas); however, mine is going to be a little bit different from the others I’ve seen floating around.  As of today, I’ve only finished five games on the dates indicated:

  1. World of Final Fantasy – 2/19/17
  2. Journey – 3/22/17
  3. The Room – 5/16/17
  4. The Room Two – 5/27/17
  5. The Room Three – 8/15/17

There’s no doubt which the best game out of all of those is.

Obviously, I loved WOFF and The Room series was one of the best for puzzle games ever, but you can see how I’m not really in a position to adequately talk about games based solely on the ones I played this year.  However, since I did watch a ton of Let’s Plays, I feel as though that would be the better population from which to draw my Top 10.  So without further ado…

10. Detention

Though this initially comes off as a spooky/horror game, it’s much more.  Have no doubt, there are harrowing parts (those really tall ghosts.  Hell.  No), but that’s not the inner spirit of the experience.

9. The Witch’s House

There’s a lot to be said about a game where you’re killed by a teddy bear, and I said a bit of it here with my review.  Created with RPG Maker, don’t let the cute, sprite graphics lull you into a false sense of security.  You will die.  A lot.  Gruesomely. And shockingly.  The puzzles are quite clever, and the RPG mechanic works surprisingly well for a horror game.  I also cannot stress how much the ending messes you up and literally turns everything on its ear.  It’s worth it just to play through for that.

8. Inside

In the vein of games with shocking endings, Inside notches it up to the “what the absolute fuck?!” level.  At no point did I expect to see what I saw, and where The Witch’s House is heartbreaking in its horror, Inside is flat out disturbing, but absolutely fitting for the setting.  The game is exactly what you’d expect from the creators of Limbo.  It has similar gameplay, but the story goes much deeper and, as such, is ripe for the theorists.

7. Rakuen

I had to scramble to place this in my Top 10, because I just finished it the other day.  I knew it was going to be a tearjerker when I saw the hospital setting, and I figured out what was going to happen at the end, but that did nothing to lessen the sorrow.  This is a beautiful game that expertly weaves a far too recent and real life tragedy with a parallel fantasy world.  What your character (called only The Boy) does in Morizora’s Forest is echoed in his hospital home, and this goes for the people he helps.

Rakuen is a puzzle game that plays like an RPG without the random battles, so if you’re not a fan of those, you don’t have to worry about them.  This isn’t to say there aren’t any enemies, but there’s only one type (nor do I think it’s really an enemy, but that’s edging spoiler territory), and there are no confrontations with it, only avoidance.  While this was a game I could’ve played myself, there were some creepy parts that I’m glad I only had to watch.  Combined with some overly cutesy things, it gives Rakuen a bit of Mood Whiplash, but this is not a critique, merely an observation.  The soundtrack is wonderful with vocal performances that are not only gorgeous, but serve an integral part of the story.  Make sure you have some tissues ready for the end.

6. The Mass Effect Trilogy

Even though I watched the first game in 2016, I didn’t finish the other two until last year, so I’m going to count that I finished the trilogy then.  This is the only game on the list that I plan to play in the future, and I decided that based on watching the LP by Olizandri.  There’s too much to say about Mass Effect to really get into it here (and most of you probably know about it already lol), but rewatching the ending with the knowledge of what came before under my belt completely changed my perspective on it (either that or the ending was updated to show more than what happened to Joker and EDI; I’m really not sure).  I have a great deal to say about it  when I finally get to my review in addition to comparative essays (e.g. how Reaper indoctrination is similar to the also hive-minded Jenova’s mental manipulation), and I’m looking forward to exploring all of its angles and discussing it with all of you fine people when I do.

5. Little Nightmares

I’ve watched both the original game and the two currently released DLCs, and, were it a game I could conceivably play (if I wasn’t a wuss puss), I’d have no problems doling out the ducats for all.  The DLCs are apparently inexpensive yet quite expansive in both exploration and storytelling.  There are traces and hints of what went on in the main game all throughout, though just the former is enough to give me full fledged nightmares for days (nothing little about that).  There are no cut scenes, and players are obliged to piece together the story from what can be observed in the levels.  Like Inside there are quite a few theory videos out there to either explain or spark new perspectives.  Whether you play this game in the light of day to ward off the eeriness or in the midst of darkness where the nightmares prowl is entirely up to you.  I, for one, will continue watching my Let’s Plays in the sun and covering my face at necessary moments.

4. Ori and the Blind Forest

This game is literally a work of art.  From the visuals to the music to the poignant story, Ori bookended me with tears.  While not wholly tragic, the game uses sorrow for emphasis and forces you to examine where your full allegiances lie.  I did an almost about face about a particular character once their true motivation was known.  Moon Studios should be both commended and supported for future endeavors.

I considered stopping the LP when I first started so I could play myself, but I’m glad I just continued watching.  There is no way in hell I could pull off those sweet, platforming moves that Cry so brilliantly preformed (though there was some Power of Editing involved lol.  No hate though).  It’s a Metroidvania game, so there’s a lot of backtracking to open up areas previously unattainable.  Also, did I mention the soundtrack?  I did?  Well let me mention it again, because I need to download it.

P.S. The name of the setting is the Forest of Nibel and there’s both fire and mist.

3. Valiant Hearts: The Great War

Ya’ll if you want to ugly cry, please play or watch this game.  Where Ori had me misty (hey that’s what “Nibel” means!), Valiant Hearts made me bawl.  My husband stopped playing Destiny 2 to make sure I was okay, and the friend he was playing with asked if everything was alright.  THAT’S how serious I am about what this game did to me, and it’s not even what you’d expect.  It hits hardest because it’s unexpected and just so wrong.  There’s a wonderful video by The Closer Look called “How to Make the Audience Cry,” and it explains what concept universally causes it and why.  I’d recommend watching it only if or after you’ve watched/played Valiant Hearts.  It’s not a major spoiler, but a game/story like this should be experienced untainted.

2. The Last of Us

I had a long talk with myself about whether this or the number one game would have that place, but in the end, I decided it based on after effects.  Which story haunted me more?  Which caused more of an existential crisis?  While TLOU certainly vied with the first question (especially in any intelligent discussions about it), the number one pick literally blew the second out of the water, but that doesn’t mean the tale of Joel and Ellie is worth any less.  It is a very close second, and, along with the first, is one of my more essay-like reviews.  I have a lot to say about this game, and I see the ending from multiple different points of view.  Understanding loss, I understand why what happened did, but I can also see why there is a great deal of negativity about the decision and the game mechanic that makes you (the player) part of something you might find reprehensible.  Because I not only suck at stealth (seriously…you should see me in Assassin’s Creed: Origins.  It would be embarrassing if I had any shame…), I’m also a wuss puss when it comes to any kind of horror, and I utterly abhor being chased.  When something like this comes after you…

…TSN says nope and covers her face.

I was also completely wrong about Ellie’s peculiar attribute in terms of what caused it, and that was proven with one of the saddest deaths in the game.  Then when I thought I’d figured it out again, that wasn’t the case either.  However, while I might rail against my inelegance, I’m often happy to be wrong in these cases, because it means I could use my “wrong” suppositions in a story of my own and I get to be surprised!

Speaking of which…I have a soft spot in my heart for TLOU, because it has damn near the same plot as the first novel I wrote.  In a different setting and a different relationship between the “Joel” and “Ellie” characters, but “experienced, morally grey bad ass with a devastating loss in his past (that he witnessed first hand) hired to take an inexperienced, young woman to pre-determined location and on the way they learn to love each other” plus the spoilery stuff at the end of TLOU is exactly the same, and I’m a bit shook.

This is one of those games that every gamer should experience.  I’m not one of those “hates cut scenes” people so they don’t bother me in the least, enhancing the narrative rather than taking away especially in this case.  I can’t wait for the second part to come out.

And my number one game of 2017 is…


There’s no delicate way to put this.  This game fucked me up…badly.  I was messed up for weeks.  It might not be far fetched to say that I’ve never been so directly fucked up by a video game before.  Oh, the Metroid series scares me with its monsters (especially Mother Brain *shudder*) and of course Final Fantasy VII certainly has its Fridge Logic and Fridge Horror aspects, but SOMA’s ending hits you like a leviathan right then and right there.  As soon as it happens, it all comes together, and you realize the truth that you’ve already seen demonstrated, but because Simon believes, you don’t really give it a second thought…until the end.  Then all of the existential horror just comes crashing down.

What is consciousness?  That is the quintessential question SOMA asks.  Without it, we couldn’t experience this world we live in.  We could have neither the overwhelming pleasure nor existential horror.  You couldn’t be reading my words right now.  I could neither have watched SOMA nor would SOMA itself exist.  Consciousness is the only idea that has to exist for anything else to have meaning.  The only way to study the brain is to use the brain, and we, as humans, are brains trying to understand themselves.  No other entity is like that.  If you want to study a star or a bird, you don’t use a star or a bird (though you might have them for reference); you use your (conscious) brain.  Just like you can’t talk about language without using language, you can’t talk about the brain without using the brain.  SOMA takes consciousness, the brain, the thing that makes you you, and renders it into almost a commodity.  We all see ourselves as individuals and our experiences as unique. My red is not necessarily your red.  There’s an ineffable quality to the human conscious experience, and SOMA questions it all.

I studied psychology in college almost twenty years ago, and though there have been marvelous advances in that field, we are still not much closer to understanding what consciousness is.  Does it arise from the complexity of neural connections and brain structures or is it something received from elsewhere?  When did it first arise?  What were the first creatures to gain a semblance of consciousness?  How does your conscious experience differ, and is there any way of knowing or even explaining how it differs?  Despite these questions being heavy handed, SOMA really isn’t.  It doesn’t pound them into your head, it just lays them out for you to stumble upon.

The true horror is how normal Simon is.  He’s not a doctor or a researcher or a marine biologist.  He’s just a guy from Toronto who works at a bookstore.  A fatal car accident led him to require special treatment and get a brain scan, and the game completely messes with your sense of time, but you don’t realize that until more information is revealed.

This is another very long review.  It’s more essay at this point requiring prerequisite reading and research so I can adequately discuss it.  If you haven’t played or watched this, I couldn’t recommend it more, and Mr. Odd is an excellent LPer with reactions similar to what mine would be (though this is another “Nope” game, because “monsters” chase you.  The quotes are important…and disturbing), but Cryaotic has one as well.  I wish SOMA wasn’t a one and done type of game for me, because I know Cry’s play-through is probably epic.

Though I haven’t watched any of the Amnesias, I think I can safely say that SOMA is Frictional Games’ greatest work.  Though I believe this about all of the games on my list, this one here is not one you should pass up.  Even if it leaves you like I was for weeks unable to sleep because of what a mind fuck it is…I still believe it was worth it.

I hope you enjoyed my Top 10 Let’s Play list!  Are there any games you’d add to this?  What were your Top 10 in 2017?  Were they released in 2017 or did you just play them then?  I can’t wait to hear what you think in the comments, and may 2018 be an even better gaming year than the prior.


44 thoughts on “TSN’s 2017 Top Games List

      • I’m just glad you enjoyed his stuff! And Odd’s! You know you’ve found a good streamer when you can watch literally anything they play, whether you’re interested in the game or not. I need to find someone who has a similar high quality that does Nintendo stuff. I like Oliz, but some vids are a bit too shrill to mellow out to.

        Liked by 1 person

        • I was just talking about that on Athena’s blog! I’m about 50/50 on that I think. I think I’m more likely to watch things I was on the fence about if it’s an LPer I like, and when I find a game I’ve been dying to watch done by one of them it’s like double jackpot!

          Yeah, I can see that. He’s super enthusiastic, and I like him (oddly) because he’s family friendly, not that I have any kids lol. I think I like being able to share Let’s Players with IRL friends and many of them have little ones who’d enjoy watching games, but obviously want it to be appropriate.

          Hm, I’ll keep my eyes open for a Nintendo LPer. I know I’ve seen some.


                • Olizandri has one! I just started watching his LP of Paper Mario: Color Splash. I’ve head disparaging things about the battle system, but I still wanted to check out the game since like the PM series so much. It does seem overly complicated though.


                    • Agreed. I looked it up while I was commenting, and I wouldn’t be able to watch it.

                      I’d need a Wii U just to play it! So that’s two games I need that system for, possibly three since Captain Toad is on it. I’d love for Nintendo to release these on the Switch.


                    • Also not good, haha. The non-RPG Paper Mario games have left a lot to be desired, but I haven’t gotten to Super Paper Mario yet.

                      They’re porting DKC Tropical Freeze (one of my favorite platformers ever made) and Hyrule Warriors (which I will 100% rebuy for all the DLC content I missed out on). Bayonetta 1 & 2 as well! Yay!

                      Hopefully they port Wonderful 101, Xenoblade Chronicles X, the New Super Mario Bros + Luigi U combo, Super Mario 3D World, Yoshi’s Woolly World, Captain Toad, and Tokyo Mirage Sessions at some point. Loads of great stuff that was just stranded on Wii U and never played by the masses.

                      Liked by 1 person

                    • Super PM would’ve been amazing as a turn based RPG. I loved everything about it except for that. I was kind of bummed because I’d want to play it, but I didn’t want to deal ith the combat lol. It’s the first and only Mario game to make me cry near the end and after you beat it. Now as I’m sure has been established, I’m a big old cry baby, but it really did get me..

                      They need to get on that! Especially if they’re going to start charging for the online service. I don’t know what one has to do with the other, but it just makes sense in my head.


    • omfg my hubby asked me about that and I nearly shit my pants just thinking about it. I can’t even imagine how horrifying a game like that would be in VR. Any horror game would cause heart attacks in such a setting. Hell I’m kind of worried about playing Thumper like that lol.


  1. Pingback: Year In Review and Future of My Blog Moving Forward in 2018 – Drakulus

  2. TLOU definitely stayed with me for a bit. I haven’t played a lot of those games you mentioned, but I’m not in the right mental state to be messed up like that yet, haha…. sigh. Anyway, you had a really productive year! I enjoyed reading your thoughts on everything 🙂 I do hope I get to Mass Effect sometime this year.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Nooooo lol. It’s like the games I watched were either heartbreakingly sad or shit your pants scary 😀 I’m currently watching Okami, which has a Legend of Zelda like feel to it. I really want to catch up on my reviews, but TLOU and SOMA are pretty much dissertations at this point :p

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Great list! 😀 I would really love to play some of these. *Reminds myself to start making more time for gaming again this year.* I just recently went to a local brewery for the first time and I can’t even begin to tell you how excited I was to see that each of the tables had a different old school video game console on it. I don’t think I’ve ever table hopped like that before. lol

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Pingback: The State of the Gamer: 1/9/18 | The Shameful Narcissist Speaks

  5. Games where you are killed by a teddy are certainly something. That’s why I like Danganronpa!

    Valiant Hearts certainly ends on a tearjerker. Don’t worry, you are not alone. Youtube has a few clips of Let’s Players sobbing at the finale.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Pingback: The State of the Writer: 1/14/18 | The Shameful Narcissist Speaks

  7. Sorry, missed this post earlier I guess! I just finished playing Little Nightmares. It was so creepy. I really liked it though. Valiant Hearts is such a moving story and underrated game as well. Not surprised that one started up the waterworks for you!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Have you checked out the DLCs for it yet? They were just as good and expanded the story. Even though I watched instead of played them, I feel like that’s what DLCs *should* be doing.

      Ugh, ugly cry all up in this bitch haha. I know I’m not alone in it. Apparently, there are YouTube reaction videos of people at the end of the game. It was heartbreaking.


  8. This is a fantastic list of games, with many titles that I’ve not heard of, let alone played. But they sound fantastic – especially all those scary sounding ones. Sounds like they had a really big impact. I need to try them out and have already made a list of games to try!

    Hope the new year is treating you well! 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thank you! This was an excellent year for watching LPs for me. I absolutely love that that’s a thing and it’s all over YouTube. It’s great for both players AND watchers, especially if the latter doesn’t have the ability or time to play. Heck, I’m even currently watching Mario Odyssey which I just finished myself this weekend, but the LPer is so much better at finding Power Moons than I am lol.

      If you watch any scary ones, let me know what you think! I just received Claire the Extended Cut from my blogger friend who happens to be one of the devs, and I want to play it, BUT I’m a big wuss puss, too lol.

      Liked by 1 person

      • I totally agree. LPs are great. 🙂 Aha yeah I feel you. I like horror games, but I don’t tend to play them on my own (I’m secretly a wuss too but don’t tell my friends they think I’m brave) lucky you having a Dev friend! 🙂 Hearing interesting things about Claire. Hope you enjoy it

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.