I receive a whole hell of lot of these for someone who hates sunlight :p
This time I was nominated by Extra Life Reviews who does just that. He gives out extra lives and reviews. Wait…maybe it’s just that his reviews give extra life to all those who read them. You won’t know which one it is unless you check his blog out, now will you? I always appreciate every nomination I receive, and I can only apologize for how long it’s taken me to get to this one. So without further ado, here are the questions I was asked to answer.
1. In which cases would you deem the manga superior to the anime on which it’s based?
Hm, I’ve fallen quite far behind in my anime viewing, not for lack of desire, just lack of time. It’s been a while since I’ve watched any, and lining up something that I’ve both watched the anime of and read the manga is a bit difficult. I’ll say that the Chobits manga was more detailed than I remember the anime being (though I watched it a long time ago), although there were things in both media representations that were way ickier to my more 2019 sensibilities.
2. Which game do you feel has the best soundtrack?
Omg don’t do this to me. There are way too many choices out there. If you know me, you know I’d have to pick one of the Final Fantasies, and I believe I’ve already decided that Final Fantasy IV has the best soundtrack in terms of overall quality. There are songs I like better on other OSTs, but nearly every song in IV is excellent. For non-Final Fantasy (you evil, evil thing)…I literally can’t decide so I’m just going to throw some great ones out there.
- The Legend of Zelda (all of them)
- Ori and the Blind Forest
- Octopath Traveler
3. If you could revive a dead video games series, which one would you choose?
Golden Sun. I only watched Let’s Plays of it and never played it myself, but I’d like to see another in the series. While the third wasn’t nearly as good as the first two, I think a lot of that had to do with the marked differences in gameplay. Also Dark Dawn was only the first half of a story just like the first Golden Sun, so…Camelot Software Planning maybe should’ve planned better.
4. What game/film/album/book did you have a particularly difficult time adding to your collection?
It took me quite a long time to find a copy of Susan Kay’s Phantom until sometime last year because it was out of print for so long.
It’s a retelling of the famous Phantom of the Opera originally by Gaston Leroux (which I’ve read and have a LOT to say about), but for a while any copies were wildly expensive. I was finally able to pick one up last year along with Leroux’s original novel.
5. Do you prefer to see a film at home or in the theaters?
It depends on the film. Certain films I like to see in the theater. Even though I hate people, I love gatherings where everyone is on the same page and hype about the same thing. The experience of seeing Avengers: Endgame is not something I’d trade, because everyone there was of a similar mind. We all yelled, laughed, cried, and cheered at the same moments. There’s just something about being amongst strangers yet feelings so connected to that portion of humanity. You know that you could strike up a conversation about the experience with any of them, and their energy would feed your energy and inverse. It’s magical.
6. In what cases did you find yourself siding with critics over fans about a work’s quality?
I’ll have to answer this with some caveats, because while critics are generally considered “experts,” their opinion is still not entirely objective, and a work can be considered “low quality,” yet still give enjoyment. That being said Twilight and Fifty Shades of Grey. I’ve curbed a lot of my more virulent critiques over the years, but that doesn’t mean there aren’t valid criticisms of these works (e.g. promoting abusive relationships), but the enjoyment of them by certain demographics is fraught with so many nuances that not only reflect what we are as a society, but also show how such novels came to be written and popular in the first place. As someone who participates in what’s often considered frivolous, i.e. both writing and reading fanfiction, I have to recognize this and even call out my past self for her classist behavior.
7. In what cases did you find yourself siding with fans over critics about a work’s quality?
I honestly can’t think of an answer to this one, lol. To be fair, I don’t read or listen to a lot of professional critics, and tbh you could be both a critic and a fan. I guess this will be one I don’t really answer.
8. What is the most difficult game you’ve completed?
It had to be something I played when I was younger, because current TSN doesn’t play difficult games lol. I did beat Super Mario World’s Rainbow Road back in the day, but that’s a difficult part and not such much a difficult game. The Adventures of Lolo 3 was pretty damn hard in terms of puzzlers, and I believe I beat that with no guide, because they didn’t exist back then. I guess we’ll go with that unless I think of something else.
9. Which game series have you been following for the longest amount of time?
Probably Super Mario, but I’d also have to say Final Fantasy and Legend of Zelda.
10. In what ways do you feel video game critics to be ahead of their film-loving counterparts?
They’re way less dismissive. There are still film critics out there (albeit older ones) who don’t think video games are a viable medium for critique, clearly forgetting that all narratives are worthy of discourse. I also think that game critics have to contend with more moving parts. For example if you’re discussing a narrative based game, you not only have to look at the narrative, you also have to look at the gameplay and how that connects (or doesn’t) to the story that’s being told. Since games are an interactive medium, you are a part of it even if you’re just playing a role or along for the ride. You are controlling at least one character, and this made a monumental difference in games like The Last of Us and Shadow of the Colossus. With the former, it left many players in a state of disgust for what they were forced to do as Joel at the end, and with Shadow, the realization of who/what you are is all the more jarring when you realize all you’ve done to get there. Even in older games like Final Fantasy VII, which are literally role-playing, you’re controlling Cloud at one point as he slaps/beats up Aeris and later as he struggles not to kill her. Even though you’re not that character, you’re pressing the buttons and controlling the uncontrollable action at that moment. I could wax philosophical about free will, but I don’t want this to be a dissertation. Even though all narratives at least attempt to give the viewer a point of view to cling to, video games more readily force you into the pilot seat through interaction.
11. How does hype factor into how you ultimately feel about a work?
Hm, this is a complicated question because it depends on the work; it depends on any preconceived notions I already had about the work; and it depends on my mental state at any given time. I have depression and anxiety, and one of my coping mechanisms with the latter is to not get excited about things, because it inevitably leads to disappointment. So something like the FFVII Remake initially caused the excitement that produced bittersweet tears, but then as I found out more, the disappointment sunk in. I was upset it wasn’t going to be turn based, and I also worried Squeenix would do too many changes to the story in order to appeal to a modern audience. I went through a non-caring phase about it, ignoring any news (though that’s kind of hard when you’re known as the FFVII lady and people will just send you shit lol), but eventually, I got to a point where I was meh. I’m looking forward to playing it, but I’m not really looking at it as “my” FFVII. I’d hoped for a remake with the updated graphics we’ve been shown and no story changes.
So I guess what I’m saying is I tend to not react as positively to hype on certain things, but if it’s something I’ve just gotten into then I’m more prone to it. It really depends. I was ultra hype for Avengers: Endgame, and I was not disappointed. ♥
Okay, well that’s it. Feel free to do it if you want to! I’m too tired to think up new questions, so just answer the ones I did. TTYL!
9 thoughts on “The Sunshine Blogger Award #5”
I think most people tend to believe the manga to be better if the anime ends first or if the film adaptation occurs in the middle of its run. Otherwise, as you say, the sticking points tend to be how much detail the manga goes into or how much filler the anime has when it overtakes the manga.
You certainly picked some good ones. I think with these kinds of questions, you can’t help but pick multiple answers. I like the soundtrack to VI a bit more, but IV’s is great as well – especially the boss theme.
Golden Sun would be a great choice given that the last game ended on a cliffhanger. In general, I’m not a fan of sequel hooks because they give writers an excuse not to write a third act, and if the sequel is never made, then it falls flat.
I’ve definitely had a difficult time adding obscure works to my collection. I was so glad when Orson Welles’s The Magnificent Ambersons got a Criterion release for that exact reason.
And while I do like watching films in theaters immediately and distinguish myself from other critics in that I don’t hate people, I see why one would be more reserved. I can definitely say watching Endgame in a crowded theater was one of the best theatergoing experiences I’ve ever had. Then again, I tend to get cooperative audiences, so that’s a plus.
And yeah, Twilight and Fifty Shades is a case in which I could never trust the fans’ judgement. At the same time, you have to realize every generation ends up latching onto stupid stuff and recent affronts to good taste are always going to feel worse than old slights – even if the latter are worse. It doesn’t mean the public’s taste is getting worse. For a positive example, I sided with the critics over the fans when it comes to The Lost City of Z.
I have to say OneShot is a case in which the fans got it right. Despite being so avant-garde with its storytelling, critics barely gave it the time of day. Then again, I find fans have been much more supportive of indie games than critics as of late, so it pays to give fellow gamers the time of day.
I did manage to complete Goldeneye on 00 Agent mode and Dark Souls. I think it helps that I can enjoy games with a variety of difficulty levels.
For me, that would be Super Mario Bros. as well.
And that’s the answer I’d go with as well. Film critics have probably the most narrow definition of what is considered good. I think it helps (or doesn’t) that the medium seems a bit more conservative than most. You can get away with a lot of high concepts in video games, comic books, music, and animation, but film circles tend to be a bit more dogmatic when it comes to what’s good or bad. When something is sold entirely on its story, they often have no idea what to do with it. Plus, there are games like Undertale that have plots that simply could not exist in other mediums.
I find hype doesn’t really factor into what I feel about a work. I was hyped to see Endgame, and it delivered. I was so glad when I finally got a chance to see The Bad Sleep Well, and it was a total disappointment. I had really low expectations for Brazil, and I thought it was great. I was dreading watching First Reformed, and it was indeed a poor effort. I think that about covers the gamut.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s literally impossible for me to pick just one video game soundtrack because the music on so many is just too good. I’m so happy to see that it’s getting its spot in the sun at least in this regard, because there are still a lot of old school critics who see games as a bastard medium. I’m not shocked because comic books held that role for a really long time, too.
Golden Sun did the same thing with the first two games, but I believe the second was always planned. I’m really hoping Dark Dawn has a sequel because I want to find out what happens in the end. It’s a really compelling story.
Endgame was amazing to see in theaters, and I think movies like that are made for a collective viewing experience because of all the time that’s been put in. You know you’re going into it with people who are on the same fan love level as you and you’ve all had this experience with the 20 movies prior.
Completely agree with film criticism being conservative. If you don’t make a movie that either stays within the mold or completely shatters it to fit into a new one, you’ve made crap in their book. Games have a much more wiggle room and you can see a lot more cross genre offerings.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ooh, definitely gonna check out the video game soundtracks you listed. 🙂 I love listening to video game music. Especially when I’m writing.
LikeLiked by 1 person
They’re SO good for that. I think I remember reading that that’s purposefully. Games have soundtracks conducive to problem solving/thinking, which makes sense!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh, cool! That’s really interesting. I’d never even thought about that before, but it totally makes sense now that you mention it. 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Blogger awards are so exciting!! Congrats!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
LikeLiked by 1 person
Pingback: The State of the Writer: 6/30/19 | The Shameful Narcissist Speaks
Pingback: Underrated Ladies! – Livid Lightning